Landscape Lighting Systems
appen grocery
Northside Oral Surgery
appen dec 2010

Time to put students first in FSA debacle

January 11, 2012
Well it is a fine mess we have with the Fulton Science Academy, a charter middle school having won top academic accolades including that of a Blue Ribbon Charter School, but no longer possessing a Fulton County Schools System charter.

It is obvious there is plenty of blame on the table for everyone to take a generous portion. The FSA Board of Directors has known for over a year exactly what the Fulton Schools System was demanding. But the FSA let other matters at hand cloud its judgment.

Its master plan had always been to create a seamless education stream kindergarten through 12th grade with its two sister schools, Fulton Science Academy High School and the Fulton Sunshine Academy elementary school.

And plans were going swimmingly, having secured the property and an $18 million construction bond to build that seamless K-12 charter school. But there were some chinks in the plan. As I understand it, FSA said it needed a 10-year charter to improve its bond rating on that big loan.

Problem is, Fulton County Schools has never awarded a charter longer than five years except for one special case in Hapeville, because it was tied to a technical training school. So the FSA board decided to play hardball with the Fulton Schools administration and never submitted the disputed paperwork Fulton Schools was demanding.

The FSA board thought it deserved a longer charter because of student performance and that longer charter would strengthen the schools' bond worthiness.

The upshot was the FSA got into a catfight with the Board of Education that somehow FSA failed to see it could not win.

They left the Board of Education with a choice of giving in or letting the FSA fail. Not surprisingly, the Board of Education chose the latter course.

Now parents have rallied to the FSA board's side along with the entire North Fulton legislative delegation asking the Board of Education to reconsider.

What surprises me is no one is calling for the resignation of the FSA board.

This board has failed in its most basic tenet, that of ensuring the school kept its charter and kept its doors open. Now that board's calculated inaction has jeopardized the hard work of FSA parents, teachers and students, it has jeopardized its sister schools who, I am told, are on the hook for this $18 million loan. The two remaining schools may not have the means to pay with FSA's doors closed for a year. This is the sin of hubris.

But now that the Board of Education has shown FSA who is boss, it would behoove the BOE to rethink its hard-line policy to deny the FSA another chance. The FSA board, suitably chastened, has agreed to do it the way Fulton County Schools wants it done.

As noted before, there are also private investors who have backed these $18 million bonds, and two other well performing charter schools may now be at risk.

The Board of Education has already shown it is willing to make special dispensations to the Hapeville charter school because it was in everybody's best interest.

Surely, the future of three charter schools and the investors who have backed the new construction can be granted a similar special dispensation that will keep its doors open. After the train wreck, FSA effusively said the school was ready to comply completely with Fulton School's policy on their charter. Why not give the school another chance to come into compliance?

This is no time for Fulton County Schools and the Board of Education to remain hard-nosed. This is a charter school that has brought national attention to good things being done in the name of local education. And this is at a time when other school systems in the state have made Georgia a national laughingstock.

I know the Board of Education and its administrators have the interests of 90,000 students to watch over, not just the 500 or so at one little charter school. But the folks who support this school and its sister institutions are working hard to provide an alternative path to education that has met Fulton County standards admirably.

As we have already seen in the Hapeville charter school, Fulton Schools does make exceptions to charter school policy where it makes sense. That is the kind of flexibility we want from school boards.

Instead, the Board of Education seems to be saying, "It's not our fault. Oh well." It is not the assessment of blame we are looking at. The question is how to solve this problem, and passing the buck is not a solution.

We have to look beyond all the finger-pointing and gnashing of teeth to see what can be done to save the situation.

I am already tired of hearing about "board policy," because what is needed now is for the Board of Education to show some of that flexibility it showed with the Hapeville school. The precedent is there. So, be the cavalry to the rescue.

The effects go beyond just what happens to these three charter schools, their students and their investors. Already in the dog-eat-dog world of economic development, corporate locators in places like Charlotte, Plano, Texas and Houston are whispering to corporate location scouts how dysfunctional our metro area education is. Why, we even close Blue Ribbon schools.

This will cost millions in economic development that might well have come here.

I think it would be a good thing, a great thing, if the Board of Education could declare this an extraordinary situation (which it is) and sit down with the FSA board and probably some bond attorneys to patch this up. Only good could come of it, and only bad if nothing is done.

emailEmail Link

Tags: Community & Outreach

  1. report print email
    A game of chicken
    January 12, 2012 | 12:58 PM

    Hatcher, Your article echos my sentiments on this issue. This more closely resembled a game of chicken, not a charter renewal. Unfortunately the students, parents and bond holders were along for the ride.

    S Lee Guy
    Alpharetta GA
  2. report print email
    January 12, 2012 | 07:55 PM

    What an embarrassment! FSA MS may have rolled the dice, but the Fulton County School Board is the one caught with its pants down. Locals and outsiders see this for what it is, muscle flexing by an arrogant school board that cannot see the forest through the trees. The parents, teachers and students of FSA do more and better with fewer tax dollars than other Fulton County schools (not to mention other schools in Georgia and around the country) yet the Fulton County Board of Education thumbs its nose at one of (if not the best) school in its system. The FCBOE is not omnipotent. Voters and taxpayers are demanding better performance from public schools and FSA is a shining example of that. Wait until this story goes national and makes it into the upcoming election season as a prime example of government getting it wrong. I can see it now, "Fulton County (government) Schools - Where students come first" unless you happen to be an outstanding charter school with broad community support.

    Milton Citizen
  3. report print email
    Good faith ?
    January 18, 2012 | 04:17 PM

    Did you know that normal renewal for a charter school is 5 years (state law) and 3 year renewals are reserved for schools in probation?

    Under normal circumstances School asks for 10 board says 3 and you meet in the middle 5-8. Of course, this would require people to have "good-faith".

    Nobody is playing chicken here. Fulton county was determined to close this school and they did everything to make that happen. Otherwise how do you explain them rejecting School's 2nd application for 3 years.

  4. report print email
    Blame game
    January 21, 2012 | 11:33 PM

    Then likewise, how do you explain FSA rejecting the BOE's 3 year term the first time around? Like Hatcher said, there's enough blame to go around. Let's give everyone a good helping of it.

    The BOE deserves a share of the blame for walking away from mediation this week. What's best at this point is to approve the three year term and move on.

    S Lee Guy
    Alpharetta GA
  5. report print email
    Blood boils
    January 22, 2012 | 01:44 PM

    Lee, it makes my blood boil that BOE wouldnt sit down at the mediation table. It's the ultimate expression of an inflated ego in my opinion. It is dissappointing that no one on the BOE is stepping up for what is right (and frankly, it should be easy politically as the public and Georgia legilsature would be behind them).

    Roger T.
  6. report print email
    January 24, 2012 | 08:56 PM

    The parents and staff of the school are the only folks who can legitimately call for the resignation of the FSA board, and I can assure you we are not doing that. I spent a lot of time in that little cafeteria this year, in open meetings, some well-attended and some not, following the plans and progress of the charter renewal process. The only thing the FSA Middle board can be faulted for is their belief that the FCBoE was composed of rational adults and would conduct business in that fashion.

When posting feedback please be respectful. Be nice. :
* required value
Your Name*


Email (not shown on website)*



Identify the animal

Coldwell Banker


September 18, 2014 | 09:17 AM
Duties include;Appointment »

Alpharetta Tax Preparer - Full Time Help

September 17, 2014 | 05:06 PM
Local Alpharetta Tax preparer »

Breakfast table and chairs

September 15, 2014 | 11:52 AM
Metal frame Glass top breakfast »

Johns Creek Chamber
appen dec 2010 Duplicate